Beyond active ingredients to sensory appeal 

PIERA PERICU
Personal Care, Health & Biosciences, IFF, Oegstgeest, the Netherlands

ABSTRACT: This opinion article delves into the burgeoning trend of “skinification” within beauty and personal care (BPC) industry, a term encompassing the integration of facial skincare principles and elements across diverse applications such as hair care and body care. Skinification puts a spotlight on active ingredients that are efficacious, but can sometimes overlook the sensory aspect of the final product. Given that many active ingredients require repeated use to determine effectiveness of performance, and these products usually instruct to use regularly for best results, it begs the question what would encourage repeated usage of a product and are formulators well-equipped for this in their product development? This article reexamines the skinification definition beyond active ingredients to the sensory appeal that can encourage consistent and prolonged use.

INTRODUCTION

“Skinification” is a term we’ve been hearing a lot of in the BPC industry in recent years. The use of this term started as early as May 2019 and has been proliferating in the BPC industry (1). Skinification refers to the incorporation of active ingredients, routines or benefits originating from facial skin care, into wider beauty and personal care applications. In hair care, for example, the popularity of skinification stems from the belief that commonly found skincare actives can provide similar benefits to the hair as they do to the skin e.g. hydration, nourishment, or protection. Skinification also emphasizes the importance of scalp care, considering it as an extension of skincare. Maintaining a healthy scalp environment can help to promote stronger, healthier hair growth but also improve hair appearance. The principles of skinification have also been extended into the hair care routine beyond cleansing, where we’ve witnessed a surge in new product developments such as scalp masks, hair oils and hair serums.


The rise of skinification likely solidified amidst the pandemic as consumers strived to maintain their beauty rituals at home, or seek solace in their beauty routines to alleviate stress during an unprecedented period. The importance of self-care becomes increasingly evident as consumers spent greater time researching products online and discovering ingredients and specific actives to treat or prevent skin concerns. Since then, ingredients traditionally found in facial skin care have started proliferating in hair care, body care, sun care, and intimate care.


As such, skinification can be said to have its roots in holistic wellness as consumers are increasingly viewing their bodies as interconnected ecosystems. This led to a holistic approach to their own mental and physical well-being where beauty routines are extended beyond looking good to maximizing pleasure, relaxation and wellness benefits. For example, according to a Mintel report, 82% of German Shower, Bath and/or Soap users think baths are a good way to relax and 79% say the same about showering (2).

REPEAT USE FOR BEST RESULTS


For customers and consumers alike, performance remains a key factor when it comes to making a purchasing decision. “Long-lasting moisture” claims is the top priority for a Euromonitor survey respondents when choosing a hand, body or footcare product (3). Efficacy is therefore a key purchase driver, so much so that 65% of facial skincare users are looking for specific ingredients within products (4).


It is important to note that the efficacy of most products is better determined after repeated usage, and some of the most effective products require repeat usage to show results. An investigation into test designs and methods studying moisturizers with hydrating effects, found that many of these studies evaluated daily application results over a period of 14 days, some up to eight weeks (5, 6, 7, 8). While test designs vary according to the claims that a product is claiming to make, good practices for optimum results are standard in-use tests performed over a 4-week minimum (with daily or twice daily application). The 4-week period is equivalent to the cells turn-over time of 28 days. This timeframe will allow the skin care actives to provide an effect that is measurable and visible.


Some examples of products claiming moisture retention are supported by statements such as “increased the moisture level of the skin by XX% after XX days of use,” and “even works for up to XX days after discontinuing use”.

This begs the question of what would drive repeated use for a consumer after purchasing the product for its efficacy to take effect? And are formulators equipped with the resources when developing a new product that would address these considerations?

BEYOND SKINIFICATION


The sensory aspect is usually the first thing a consumer notices when they try a product. A product’s texture can influence the perception of its efficacy, the way it applies to the skin can impact the willingness of a consumer to use and reuse it, and the aspect of the product itself can give an indication of how premium the formula is. In a study published in scientific journal Clinical and Experimental Dermatology, more than 88% of subjects found that emollients with a smoother and a more uniform appearance were deemed to be of better quality and looked more appealing to use (9), while Mintel reported that an easy-to-absorb texture is an important indicator of moisturizing efficacy (10).


There is no wonder that in a Euromonitor survey (3), “texture” and “fast absorbing” claims joined “long-lasting moisture” claims toward the top of consumers list of priorities when choosing hand, body or footcare products (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Priorities when choosing a hand, body or footcare product, 2023, Euromonitor.

Skinification puts a spotlight on active ingredients that are efficacious, often overlooking the sensory aspect of the final product. While consumers are in search of active ingredients that their skin can benefit from, functional ingredients contribute to the sensory of the product and are key to driving repeated usage, which in turn leads to achieving the best results of the active ingredients.


Functional ingredients are a critical component to achieving specific textures or novel formats. Polymers – both natural and synthetic - are seen as essential in beauty and personal care formulations. They directly influence the sensory, appearance, stability, and even performance of a product, and often contribute towards a consumer’s decision to buy. For instance, a fast-absorbing cream is seen as superior, as the short rub-in time implies quicker penetration of actives and therefore higher efficacy. An example of natural polymer is the use of guar gum as a thickener and sensory modifier. Guar gum (INCI: Cyamopsis Tetragonoloba (Guar) Gum) is extracted from the endosperm of the guar bean and contributes to a unique sensory profile suitable for many applications; at low levels it provides a silky, serum-like feel to a formulation, while at higher levels it offers a lubricating sensory which can also greatly ease rinse-off of a product.


Synthetic polymers have been the product of choice for many years because they can be produced and functionalized on a large scale with uniformity, and have a long shelf-life. In addition, they can be functionalized for specific properties to fit an application area. However, pressure on the BPC industry to limit the use of certain synthetic polymers – particularly those that are not biodegradable nor renewable – are driving investment into ways to replace some synthetic polymers. This means that in addition to the selection of active ingredients and the sensory appeal, sustainability also needs to be embedded in the product development process as consumers and regulators demand the BPC industry to lead the charge with increasing climate change concerns.


Formulators today must not only find ways to showcase innovation through new formats and textures, but they must also opt for sustainable alternatives that can still provide these superior sensory profiles, for example, by selecting sustainably-sourced, upcycled ingredients, the highest naturality index whenever possible, or biodegradable alternatives. This has led to innovators looking to biotechnology to fill the blank spaces in functional ingredients, and to find solutions that can help formulators deliver on consumers’ expectations of performance and sustainability.


CONCLUSION


The concept of skinification focuses on incorporating buzzworthy and efficacious facial care active ingredients into other application areas such as hair care, body care and intimate care. As presented in the article, the efficacy or performance of a product very often requires consistent and regular use. One factor that can encourage consumer’s repeated use is the texture and sensory appeal. This is not limited to innovative textures but including those that complement the claims made, for example, moisturizing creams containing long-lasting moisturization actives need to show an immediate effect on skin roughness reduction. This challenges today’s definition of skinification, stretching its boundaries to emphasize not only on active ingredients but also the intrinsic appeal of product experiences. This shift raises a pertinent question: Are formulators adequately equipped to address the needs for enticing textures that prompt consumers to repurchase? This question highlights the necessity for innovation strides in the domain. Biotechnology has emerged as a promising tool to deliver solutions that can be both performance-oriented and fulfil consumers’ demands on sustainability. In conclusion, skinification pivots on the harmonious fusion of effectiveness, sensoriality and sustainability.


About the Author

PIERA PERICU

With 20 years experience in the industrial biotech industry, Piera Pericu has profound knowledge and understanding of the challenges in various industrial processing markets. Previously in DuPont, she was Global Application Team Leader focused on developing sustainable solutions in textile processing and Product Manager for the GENENCARE® OSMS product line. In her current role as Market Segment Leader for Personal Care, she is responsible for the advanced programs and new product launches in the active and functional spaces.

PIERA PERICU​​​​​​​

Personal Care, Health & Biosciences, IFF, Oegstgeest, the Netherlands

References and notes

  1. Google Trends (n.d.). "Skinification". Retrieved December, 14 2023
  2. Officer, D. (October 27, 2023) A year of innovation in soap, bath & shower, 2023. Mintel.
  3. Euromonitor International Voice of the Consumer: Beauty Survey 2023.
  4. Officer, D. (October 13, 2023) Facial skincare format and ingredient trends – UK, 2023. Mintel.
  5. Samadi A, Nasrollahi SA, Rostami MN, Rezagholi Z, Abolghasemi F, Firooz A. Long-term effects of two 24-hour moisturizing products on skin barrier structure and function: A biometric and molecular study. Health Sci Rep. 2021 Jun 6;4(2):e308. doi: 10.1002/hsr2.308. PMID: 34141902; PMCID: PMC8180516.
  6. Accessed online: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34141902/

  7. McDaniel DH, Dover JS, Wortzman M, Nelson DB. In vitro and in vivo evaluation of a moisture treatment cream containing three critical elements of natural skin moisturization. J Cosmet Dermatol. 2020 May;19(5):1121-1128. doi: 10.1111/jocd.13359. Epub 2020 Mar 6. PMID: 32141711; PMCID: PMC7217153.
  8. Accessed online: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32141711/

  9. Ueda, Y., Murakami, Y., Saya, Yumiko, Matsunaka, H. Optimal application method of a moisturizer on the basis on skin physiological functions. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology. 2021 Vol 21(7)
  10. Draelos ZD, Hall S, Munsick C. A 14-day Controlled Study Assessing Qualitative Improvement with 15% Lactic Acid and Ceramides in Skin Moisturization and Desquamation. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2020 Aug;13(8):E54-E58. Epub 2020 Aug 1. PMID: 33178384; PMCID: PMC7595367.
  11. Accessed online: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33178384/

  12. Antonijević, M.D., Owusu-Ware, S. and Sanchon-Lopez, B. (2018), Emollient product design: objective measurements of formulation structure, texture and performance, and subjective assessments of user acceptability. Clin Exp Dermatol, 43: 423-429.
  13. Accessed online: https://academic.oup.com/ced/article/43/4/423/6597355

    White Boehm, J. Shampoo, Conditioner and Hairstyling Products – US. 2023. Mintel.

    Accessed online: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jocd.14560