Panelist

Elisa Altieri

Market Manager Personal Care, Roelmi HPC

SUSTAINABLE SOURCING AND PROCUREMENT IN THE COSMETICS INDUSTRY


Introduction
The cosmetics industry, known for its innovation and vast range of products, has a significant impact on both the environment and society. With rising consumer awareness and demand for ethical and eco-friendly products, sustainable sourcing and procurement have become paramount. This article delves into the importance, challenges, and strategies of sustainable sourcing and procurement in the cosmetics industry.


The Importance of Sustainable Sourcing
Sustainable sourcing refers to the process of obtaining raw materials in a way that respects the environment and society. In the cosmetics industry, this involves ensuring that ingredients are harvested without depleting natural resources, exploiting workers, or causing environmental degradation. Sustainable sourcing is critical for several reasons:


  1. Environmental Protection: Many cosmetic ingredients are derived from plants and natural sources. Unsustainable practices, such as over-harvesting and deforestation, can lead to biodiversity loss and environmental destruction. Sustainable sourcing ensures the preservation of ecosystems and the reduction of carbon footprints.
  2. Social Responsibility: Ethical sourcing practices ensure fair wages, safe working conditions, and community development. This is particularly important in regions where raw materials are harvested, often in developing countries.
  3. Consumer Trust and Brand Loyalty: Modern consumers are increasingly concerned about the origin and impact of the products they purchase. Brands that prioritize sustainability can build stronger relationships with their customers, fostering trust and loyalty.
  4. Regulatory Compliance: Governments and international organizations are imposing stricter regulations on environmental and social impacts. Companies adhering to sustainable practices are better positioned to comply with these regulations and avoid legal repercussions.


Challenges in Sustainable Sourcing
While the benefits of sustainable sourcing are clear, implementing these practices is fraught with challenges:

  1. Supply Chain Complexity: The cosmetics supply chain is often global and intricate, involving multiple stakeholders from raw material suppliers to manufacturers. Ensuring sustainability across this chain requires transparency and coordination, which can be difficult to achieve.
  2. Cost Implications: Sustainable sourcing can be more expensive due to the need for certifications, audits, and sometimes higher costs of raw materials. This financial burden can be challenging, especially for smaller companies.
  3. Verification and Certification: Authenticating the sustainability of sources can be complicated. Certifications like Fair Trade, Organic, and Rainforest Alliance provide some assurance, but the process of obtaining these certifications can be rigorous and time-consuming.
  4. Market Dynamics: Fluctuations in the availability and price of sustainable raw materials can disrupt supply chains. Companies need to develop strategies to mitigate these risks.


Strategies for Sustainable Sourcing
Despite the challenges, there are several strategies that companies in the cosmetics industry can adopt to ensure sustainable sourcing:


  1. Partnerships and Collaborations: Forming partnerships with suppliers, NGOs, and other stakeholders can help companies implement sustainable practices. Collaborative efforts can lead to better resource management and community development.
  2. Traceability Systems: Implementing traceability systems allows companies to track raw materials from their source to the final product. This transparency helps ensure that sustainable practices are being followed at every stage of the supply chain.
  3. Supplier Audits and Engagement: Regular audits of suppliers can help ensure compliance with sustainability standards. Engaging suppliers in sustainability initiatives and providing them with support and incentives can foster long-term commitment.
  4. Innovation in Ingredients: Research and development of sustainable alternatives to traditional ingredients can reduce environmental impact. For example, sourcing synthetic or lab-grown ingredients can minimize the depletion of natural resources.
  5. Consumer Education: Educating consumers about the importance of sustainability and the efforts being made can drive demand for sustainably sourced products. This can also justify higher prices and build brand loyalty.


Sustainable Procurement Practices
Sustainable procurement extends beyond sourcing raw materials to include the entire procurement process. It encompasses selecting suppliers, purchasing decisions, and the overall impact of procurement activities. Key practices include:


  1. Sustainable Supplier Selection: Choosing suppliers who adhere to environmental and social standards is crucial. This involves evaluating suppliers based on their sustainability practices, certifications, and ethical standards.
  2. Life Cycle Assessment: Conducting life cycle assessments of products can help companies understand the environmental impact of their procurement decisions. This assessment considers the entire life cycle of a product, from raw material extraction to disposal.
  3. Green Packaging: Packaging is a significant aspect of procurement. Opting for recyclable, biodegradable, or minimal packaging can reduce waste and environmental impact.
  4. Sustainable Logistics: Efficient logistics and transportation can reduce carbon emissions. Companies can optimize routes, use eco-friendly transportation options, and consolidate shipments to minimize environmental impact.
  5. Waste Management: Implementing strategies to reduce, reuse, and recycle waste generated during the procurement process is essential. This includes minimizing packaging waste and finding innovative ways to repurpose by-products.


Case Studies
In a world increasingly marked by the challenge of water scarcity, the cosmetics industry has both the opportunity and responsibility to lead the shift towards innovative and sustainable solutions. Water, a fundamental ingredient in personal care, must be reevaluated in light of current environmental needs. It is essential to develop alternatives that not only reduce environmental impact but also elevate the standards of quality and performance of products. In response to this need, ROELMI HPC launched a line of active waters several years ago, hydrophilic extracts obtained exclusively through physical methods. These treatments respect the natural integrity of the plant, allowing the replacement of demineralized water in the formulation process with an alternative, sustainable, and ethical source. This innovation not only reduces environmental impact but also allows products to be labeled as “Waterless” or “Water-free.”


These upcycled waters are ingredients derived from a variety of Mediterranean fruits, and the extraction process is conducted in partnership with a fruit concentrate producer in southern Italy. The portfolio includes eight different active hydrophilic molecules from the following fruits: clementine (INCI: Citrus Clementina Fruit Extract), grapefruit (INCI: Citrus Grandis Fruit Extract), blood orange (INCI: Citrus Sinensis Fruit Extract), orange (INCI: Citrus Aurantium Dulcis Fruit Extract), kiwi (INCI: Actinidia Chinensis Fruit Extract), bergamot (INCI: Citrus Aurantium Bergamia Fruit Extract), mandarin (INCI: Citrus Nobilis Fruit Extract), and lemon (INCI: Citrus Limon Fruit Extract). The raw materials are harvested from high-quality Mediterranean fields and subjected to gentle physical methods to preserve their integrity. In vitro tests confirm their effectiveness in enhancing cell vitality, making them active molecules for protecting the skin from external agents and reducing inflammation (1).


Conclusion
Sustainable sourcing and procurement are critical for the cosmetics industry to minimize its environmental footprint and uphold social responsibility. While challenges exist, adopting innovative strategies, forming partnerships, and educating consumers can drive positive change. As consumer demand for ethical products continues to rise, sustainability will not only be a moral imperative but also a key driver of business success. By prioritizing sustainable practices, the cosmetics industry can contribute to a more sustainable future, benefiting both people and the planet.

References and notes

Experts

MARK SMITH

Director General, NATRUE AISBL, the International Natural and Organic Cosmetics Association

MOJGAN MODDARESI​​​​​​​

Managing director, Personal Care Regulatory Ltd, Chemcomply founder

DIPTI VAIDYANATHAN​​​​​​​

Market Transformation Manager, Europe - RSPO

LEE MANN

Head of Community Fair Trade and Sustainable Sourcing, The Body Shop

JENNIFER SHEPHERD​​​​​​​

Senior Buyer Communit, The Body Shop

EMILY HOLDEN​​​​​​​

Sustainability Relations Advisor, The Body Shop

BARBARA OLIOSO 

Director, The Green Chemist Consultancy

Panelists

LISETTE TOWNSEND

Global Director Business Development

& Marketing, Personal Care, AAK

RENATA OKI

Head of Personal Care Market Development EMEA 
BASF Personal Care and Nutrition GmbH

AMANDINE WERLE​​​​​​​

Marketing Specialist, Lucas Meyer Cosmetics by Clariant

TIMM SEIDEL​​​​​​​

Senior Sustainability Manager, Chemisches Laboratorium Dr. Kurt Richter (CLR Berlin) GmbH

ANGELINA GOSSEN 

Technical Marketing Manager, Croda GmbH

CAMILLA GRIGNANI

Marketing Specialist - Etichub srl

(Academic Spin-off – University of Pavia)

MALTE SIETZEN​​​​​​​

Head of R&D and Quality Management, Evident Ingredients GmbH

CAROLE GHERARDI

Market Segment Lead, Personal Care, Health & Biosciences, IFF

FRANK DUNLAP

Director of EHS, KensingSolutions

ROSSANA COLOMBO

Technical Manager Personal Care, Lamberti

MATHILDE ALLEGRE​​​​​​​

Global Sustainability Manager,

Lubrizol Life Science

BIANCA MCCARTHY

Global Marketing Manager, Lipotec™

Active ingredients, Lubrizol Life Science

EMINA BESIC GYENGE

Senior R&D Manager Hair Care Cosmetic Actives and Sustainability expert, RAHN AG - RAHN Cosmetic Actives

ELISA ALTIERI

Market Manager Personal care, ROELMI HPC

MARINE PASQUIER​​​​​​​

Market & Digital Manager - Beauty Care at Seppic

LUCIE BAILLY 

CSR Manager, SILAB

GAELLE BATHANY​​​​​​​

Vice President Global Marketing & Sustainability, Symrise

THOR-ERIK NYSETH

Sales and Marketing Director, Unger Fabrikker AS

ÒSCAR EXPÓSITO

CEO, CSO and co-founder, Vytrus Biotech S.A.

ELISABETTA MERLO

Regulatory Affairs, Zschimmer & Schwarz Italiana